Jumat, 03 Maret 2006

Some Things Just Don't Work Well

When I first started reporting how great remote site feeding was to my best friend, The Murph, we got into long discussions regarding the various techniques we could use to analyze operating data. One of the top of the line MBA analytical techniques is multiple regression. Since some contracts required prices per manday with extra charges for special meals, we thought MR was the way to go. You could never get the general managers and operations directors too much food cost data. Serious craving!

Armed with our APL keyboards and an IBM mainframe, we started loading meal statistics into tables. I had weekly food cost numbers available by category and summary. A typical record would include weekly data as follows: Week, Breakfasts, Lunches, Dinners, Midnight Meals, Take Out Lunches, Mandays, Food Cost (in dollars). We included employee meal counts in the details and totals.

After many attempts to get a better fit using multiple regression analyses, I found simple linear regression always worked better. Food cost is highly variable. If you find a large fixed component, it is often a danger sign.

I recently ran regression statistics on some quarterly data available at the SEC's Edgar site. One steak house concept with predominantly company-owned units runs a 36% food cost. The regression line is actually 40% variable with a negative fixed component. Try to figure that out!

The notes to their financial statements are very clear and open. However, they do not address menu pricing strategy.

My best guess is they have a menu pricing strategy which adds a fixed dollar profit into every menu item to cover overhead. So to calculate a menu price, they multiply the standard recipe cost by 2.5 and add a factor to cover the overhead costs. Maybe this was a reaction to the increase in oil prices.


Click Here For More Information

Senin, 27 Februari 2006

Cultural Evolution

There are many influences which help to define a company's culture. When the company is involved in food service, the cultural themes often have a major impact on profit. I have visited operations where cleanliness was a dominant theme. From the entrance, to the dining room, kitchen, restrooms and even the loading dock and dumpsters, everything looks sanitary and safe.

My grandmother had two major criteria for restaurant selection: a full parking lot and clean restrooms. When we were out shopping, she would look for busy places to go for dinner. Once inside, she would ask where the restrooms were located before being seated. We never stayed for dinner if the place failed inspection.

Some operators never want to run out of food. They tend to buy too much and produce far more than required. Other operators are worried about selection. They focus on menu monotony. When their stamp of approval hits a menu revision, it's sure to be loaded with new items.

My favorite managers create a culture which rewards consistency. As a restaurant patron, I highly prefer operations with consistent standards. It is not uncommon to find the "consistency theme" in a restaurant with the "never run out" philosophy as well. If you consistently find your garbage cans loaded with spoiled produce and unused prep items, I have some straightforward advice. Do not try to change the culture through a complete makeover.

Find out how food is ordered and how prep requirements are calculated. Often, you'll hear the chef likes a 10% cushion or a 5% safety factor. Institute a policy change in stages. In stage one, change the slack to 80% of the previous factor (i.e. 8% vs. 10%). I like a 2.5% safety factor for most operations. Improved forecasts should reduce the need for higher figures.

Anyone who has seen the managers work the chalkboards at the Chesnut Hill Legal Seafood location can appreciate the alternative philosophy which encourages stockouts: "If it isn't fresh, it isn't Legal." We had countless meals there and brought plenty of out-of-towners. Spoiled fish was never a concern. Legal Seafood is not a client of mine but I imagine they abhor waste and spoilage.

Jumat, 24 Februari 2006

Don't Destroy Your Stars

One of the absolute and totally rigid laws of effective food cost control almost never to be challenged: Do NOT alter your signature recipes with lower quality alternatives strictly to create a lower cost.

After years of new and improved commercials, corporate brand managers watched the results of the New Coke campaign. My friend (a huge Coke fan) wrote to Coca Cola. To Coke's credit, they brought back the old formula.

A great article "If A Little Cost Cutting Is Good, Then Can A Little More Be Bad??" was presented in the February 2004 Newsletter of the Operations Management Center. The article demonstrates the key difference between value enhancement and cost cutting as a strategy.
Related Posts Plugin for WordPress, Blogger...