Tampilkan postingan dengan label forecasts. Tampilkan semua postingan
Tampilkan postingan dengan label forecasts. Tampilkan semua postingan

Rabu, 27 April 2011

Reader Question on Food Cost in Health Related Lodging

Dear Joe,

I have a question regarding Food cost in the Hotel, specializing on the Medical treatments (more like a Sanatorium).
They have a 3 times a day big buffet style meals - all inclusive.
All guests (patients) are assigned to different diets and picking up food according to their diet class.
I am Financial Controller of this hotel and when I see Food cost equal to 46% every month – I feel that it is very high for the buffet food.
Please advice if there are any benchmarks for this kind of Hotels – sanatoriums (All inclusive).

Thank you in advance,
Maria

Your 46% food cost may still deliver a profit, Maria.  If you have a very reliable (close to 100% accurate) revenue forecast due to the nature of your business, a higher cost of goods sold may be the industry norm.  Generally, everyone dines in the hotel and the buffet is a fixed price.  This creates the environment for the highly reliable forecast.

The buffet style of service keeps dining room staff size low.

We would have to know the cost dynamics in the front desk, marketing, rooms and housekeeping operations.  Is the 46% based on food sales?  Or based on total sales?

If the 46% food cost percentage equals food cost of sales divided by food sales, you will still be profitable.  This is not a benchmark issue.  Most hotels depend on last minute reservations, walk in guests and local dining guests to hit their sales targets.  They use the room count to forecast revenue but the forecast variance in sales is higher than an operation in your niche.

I use a 10% factor for food cost improvement.  In your case, we would use a 4.6% drop as our goal.  This is simply 46% times 10%.  To achieve a 4.6% improvement in a buffet style operation requires effective production controls.  If you offer a selection of protein choices, this is the best place to start.

Closely monitor the production of all buffet pans with protein.  Observe how the expected guest count and preference factors are used to forecast consumption of each menu selection.  Monitor the actual portions produced, served, left over, and/or discarded.  Over time, the numbers will help your culinary team reduce waste due to over production.

Minggu, 06 Maret 2011

10 Ways to Reduce Your Food Cost

I'd like to thank Ron and RoseAnne from ReedExpo for inviting me to speak at the International Restaurant Show in New York City this week. The show was well attended and there was excellent energy. This show is without question THE New York City restaurant show.

We had a great group attend the presentation "10 Ways to Reduce Your Food Cost Without Jeopardizing the Guest Experience" and I want to thank all the attendees.

In the New York tradition, the 10 slides are presented in reverse order, #10, #9, #8, #7, #6, #5, #4, #3, #2, and the Number 1 way to reduce your food cost:











It was tough to photograph the energetic crowd but the two photos below were taken in the middle of the floor. Every aisle had excellent traffic.


Senin, 03 Januari 2011

Outlook for 2011

I expect 2011 will usher in a new wave of job creation. This wave will take the unemployment rate down below 8% by year end. Some of the job growth will take place in the Rust Belt.

During the holiday season, I traveled to Upstate New York. The General Electric plant in Schenectady was all lit up and there were way more cars in the lot than recent years. GE will be producing batteries. AMD will be opening a brand new chip factory in Malta. The roads have been re-engineered with rotaries to handle the expected traffic volume.

Restaurant dining has become less formal in recent years. I expect this trend to continue with greater speed. Diners want to get out more often than the past few years and they want to be recognized by the management.

On our drive back, we stopped at a restaurant in Binghamton and the owner stood near the door greeting every guest. He was there as we left and we felt the traditional "Thanks for coming! Was everything OK?" seemed 100% genuine. I told him I really enjoyed the salad dressing and rolls. We ordered our salads with oil and vinegar and they offer guests a nice quality extra virgin olive oil and balsamic vinegar.

I'm going to try and patronize independently owned restaurants more this year.

There is a growing awareness of waste in the country. We will see the concern for wasted energy and clean water spread to food. Smaller portions and healthier options will be popular. Whole grain pastas, brown rice, whole grains in bread and rolls and locally grown produce will continue to get visibility in menus.

McDonald's starts the year with $1 for all sizes of coffee and soft drinks. The price pressure on non-alcoholic drinks will continue. Expect your guests to scrutinize their checks looking for prices on specials and drinks. If you price your soft drinks modestly and include the pricing on your menus, the move to complimentary tap water may start to shift back to revenue generating drink options.

With any economic uptick, we can expect market prices to increase. We ended 2010 with higher prices for gas and grains. These markets will be volatile with an upside bias.

I expect the comparable unit sales statistics to be positive in 2011. The strong concepts will see 5% plus growth. Don't expect an immediate turnaround. January is the month of New Year's resolutions which tend to give way around Super Bowl time.

Rabu, 29 Desember 2010

Tepid Jobs Recovery and Higher Grain Prices as Year Ends

The unemployment statistics are published monthly on the website run by the Bureau of Labor Statistics and there are many analysis reports supporting the published rate data.

The persistently high unemployment rate is broken down by segment in a occupation based table with every segment showing a very flat 2010. Statistics are for November 2010 vs. November 2009. On January 7, 2011, we can see December's numbers.

Will the recovery begin to add 100,000 jobs a month on average any time soon?

We are finishing the year with gas prices above $3 in most regions. This is high for this time of year. We are far from the high $4 to $5 a gallon we lived through during the summer of 2008.

The folks on AgWeb have a 17 minute audio clip focusing on high prices for grains. The clip is produced mainly for the farming industry. The industry benefits from high prices they can sell their grains for in the short run.

The worldwide demand for both food and fuel will have a major impact on the 2011 economy.

A Review of the Outlook for 2010

Around this time of year, many people give their outlook for the coming year. In my blog post Outlook for 2010 I made several predictions. All but one of the forecast items proved true:

We can expect the Federal Reserve to leave rates low until the job market turns the corner.

The overnight rate stayed between 0 and 1/4% for the entire year.

Increases in government spending at the federal level will be partially offset by cuts in local and state government budgets.

State and local governments were definitely in cut mode. The federal government spending was huge as the stimulus money was spent in many areas. Here in Northern Virginia, we see the new Metro link from Tysons Corner to Dulles Airport project dominating the landscape.

Somewhere in the later half of 2010, I expect the job market to reverse course as employers slowly start adding people to their payrolls.

Unemployment remained stubbornly high with no relief the entire year.

Stocks should continue the up and down motion as the Dow Jones seeks higher ground.

Wall Street is in the green for 2010. All key indexes are up for the year and we are currently enjoying a year end rally.

Any increase in consumer confidence will translate into profit since companies have reigned in their fixed costs. Will restaurants start filling their dining rooms mid-week?

Despite lots of restaurants seeking Chapter 11 bankruptcy protection early in the year, the industry is flat to up and creditors are allowing most reorganization plans to gain approval.

Look to travel indicators for signs of increased mid-week business. When airlines and hotels begin to see increased volumes, restaurants will find business travelers in their seats. Don't expect many $100 bottles of wine on business expense accounts this year. Frugal is in vogue.

Hotel occupancy rates have improved and the year end party news from downtown Manhattan had a frugal flavor.

I expect oil to remain below $100 per barrel.

I'm still accurate with this prediction but the markets are unseasonably high as 2010 comes to a close.

Overall, 2010 will be better than 2009 as the long slow recovery takes root.

Overall, 2010 was a big improvement over 2009 for most Americans. The big group experiencing persistent unemployment is a notable exception.

Selasa, 23 November 2010

Forecasts For Better Food Cost Results

Most restaurants have an automated ordering system (POS) which can be queried for menu item counts for any given data range. This data is quite helpful for the forecasting team in restaurants using a limited menu or a menu with a central focus (either by cuisine or main ingredient). Unwieldy menus do not allow a quick menu item count forecast (using historic POS data) to effectively buy most key items.

At the core, most forecasts begin with the cover count or number of guests expected to arrive in a given time period. Adding the check average to this cover forecast will provide the people designing a shift schedule with a target. Simply take the covers times the check average times the target labor percentage. This is the budget for the period.

Food cost control is not a percentage game in the planning phase. Although most use food cost percentage to measure results, the number won't help you predict what food to order, store, prep and bring to the line for any given period. Cover counts and check averages will provide a broad target. Making the target work is a tougher task.

For many raw ingredients, the ability to use unsold product in future meal periods has a significant impact on your food cost results. Limited menus put a short list of ingredients in play every single day. They don't need to worry how to use any leftover cheese at Domino's Pizza. Pizza is on the menu tomorrow. In contrast, operators using menus relying on daily specials for a major share of sales will have a much more demanding job to use up leftover stock.

The purchasing forecast depends on par stock targets for many shelf stable items. In a typical kitchen, a much greater share of the food cost dollar is spent on perishable meat, fish and produce. The error penalty for over ordering a shelf stable condiment is minimal when compared to fresh white fleshed fish. You will often see seafood specialists with chalkboards. Late in the dinner shift on a busy night, they want to run out of fish if the next day's forecast is for a slow Sunday or Monday.

My favorite Italian restaurant in New York does not offer fish on days when the fish market is closed (Saturday and Sunday). Some chefs pay air freight to get fresh fish in the door as fresh as possible. You want to avoid over buying any highly perishable raw ingredient. Just ask your self a simple question: "If I order more than I can use today, will I be able to sell the leftovers tomorrow?"

Once you move away from fresh fish and poultry, dairy and produce are highly perishable and are frequently purchased by specialists. If your operation doesn't justify hiring a specialist, tracking produce waste can help you adjust your pars quickly. I favor either a two-tier or three-tier par stock model. Order more before busy days and less on slow days.

I believe using sophisticated software (with menu item counts, standard recipes, standard yields and other recipe model factors) are most useful for companies who have never explored these tools. Often, my clients tell me they wish they had analyzed their menu item costs years ago.

The knowledge gained from yield analysis really improves future forecast accuracy. If you learn to translate purchase units of measure into the number of standard portions, you will have a competitive advantage. Your forecast model can now go well beyond covers, check averages and percentages. Take your top 25 items and buy more precisely. The impact is huge.

Kamis, 22 Juli 2010

Mid-Year Look Back - Outlook 2010

My most popular blog post this year is by far the Outlook 2010 which was published in early January 2010. I thought it would be interesting to see how well my predictions have fared during the first half of 2010.

We can expect the Federal Reserve to leave rates low until the job market turns the corner.


The Federal Reserve Board has cooperated with business borrowers leaving the over night federal funds rate at record low rates (zero to 1/4%).

I expect oil to remain below $100 per barrel.


Despite the BP debacle, the crude oil markets have remained in check and well below the $100 per barrel threshold.



Source: ino.com

Stocks should continue the up and down motion as the Dow Jones seeks higher ground. Any increase in consumer confidence will translate into profit since companies have reigned in their fixed costs.


Both the Dow Jones Industrial average and the broader S&P 500 index have seesawed back and forth in the search for direction. Corporate profits are definitely higher than 2009.



Source: finance.yahoo.com

Look to travel indicators for signs of increased mid-week business. When airlines and hotels begin to see increased volumes, restaurants will find business travelers in their seats. Don't expect many $100 bottles of wine on business expense accounts this year. Frugal is in vogue.


There was a short clip on CNBC today regarding higher occupancy rates at the Starwood Hotels group. Many of my clients who have a significant business expense account clientele report a gradually improving climate. Guests are reviewing check totals quite carefully.

Senin, 14 Desember 2009

How Accurate Was the Outlook for 2009?

Last year, I posted an Outlook for 2009 on December 31st. Excerpts of this post show the following expectations:
1. Oil Prices
Forecast: Oil prices finding an equilibrium higher than $60.
Reality: They stayed between $60 and $80 most of the year and currently hover near $70.
2. Interest Rates
Forecast: Low interest rates and tight credit.
Reality: This forecast was spot on.
3. Bottled Water
Forecast: Lower bottled water sales and more tap water orders.
Reality: Absolutely correct! Tap water rules in 2009.
4. Regional outlook
Forecast: Slow economy in regions with a high banking or government weight.
Reality: This is especially true in areas where the banking and government sectors had a major impact on upscale dining operations.
5. Alcoholic Beverage Trends
Forecast: More beer and less wine.
Reality: In absolute dollars, this prediction is true. What actually happened is consumers down shifted from higher priced beverages to mid-range and budget alternatives. The downshift occurred in both beer and wine.

Many of you will get a true read out on the economic future as the holiday season ends. Expect oil prices to find an equilibrium price higher than current levels. Grain prices will continue to track oil since most gasoline now has a 10% ethanol blend. Interest rates are very low allowing many businesses and consumers a chance to refinance. Credit remains very tight. Bottled water sales are in decline and tap water is becoming a popular restaurant beverage choice.

Rather than using 2007 or 2008 as your compass, try to put together a logical forecast for your region. If you operate near a major banking center, the layoffs could completely change your business model. Anyone in the Mid-West may see an increase in economic activity as stimulus dollars reach the automobile manufacturing companies. State and local governments have less revenue. If you are located in a capitol metro area, you can expect less traffic.

Americans are consuming more beer. You may want to slow down your wine list expansion. Turn a portion of your wine inventory into cash by selling slow movers by the glass. Don't be afraid to accept a higher cost of sales on these bottles. Your shelves are filled with frozen cash.


Stay tuned for the 2010 Outlook at the end of the month.

Senin, 28 September 2009

HFTP Question - Final Counts and Safety Factors

In my recent session at the HFTP Annual Convention, I gave my opinion on the use of safety factors in food service operations. Generally, purchasing managers and chefs tend to order a little extra to prevent running out of stock. While a small amount of over stock is optimal, the typical operator has too much stock of many perishable items.

A symptom of over stocked protein is a rising dollar value in freezer inventory.

During the Q&A session, I was asked about optimistic banquet event order final counts. If your sales manager tends to over estimate the final count for banquet events, the probability of spoilage and waste increases. In addition to the freezer, you may find the food in the employee cafe is better than usual. Crab cakes and Chateaubriand should not be on the employee lunch menu.

An optimistic final count number negatively impacts purchasing and production activities since the kitchen will over produce these menu items. Service staffing is also too high.

When you combine the impact of high final counts with a tendency to over order for a safety factor, it is easy to see how costs will run high in this operation. Each department uses their own safety factor to cover the risk of running out. If each department uses a 10% adjustment, you could find the sales team adds 10% to the count, the chef adds 10% to the production forecast and the purchasing manager adds 10% to the chef's order. These adjustments have the biggest impact on high cost per pound, perishable protein items. Look for the impact in freezers, garbage cans, employee meals, soups, stock pots and employee trunks.

Rabu, 31 Desember 2008

Outlook for 2009

Back in late April, I mentioned the shrinking size of the loaves of bread at our local bakery in the Smaller Portions Or Higher Prices? article. Today, we noticed the loaves have returned to their normal size. The price per loaf never changed at all during the entire period. We never bought more loaves during the eight month stretch. Actually, I think we bought less bread this year.

We had our annual HFTP Christmas Party at the Capital Hilton. I was running late and grabbed a cab for a short ride. It cost $7 to travel less than one mile. The drop fee was raised to offset higher gas prices. Nobody lowered the meter prices when oil dropped back to earth. Should you tip less to offset the obsolete pricing policy? Since I was in the holiday spirit, I tipped as usual.

With restaurant traffic down for the year, many neighborhoods have seen price wars. Even the top local restaurants here in Fairfax County have post card offers for free desserts. With lower gas prices, most families will have an extra $30 to $70 dollars each week to spend on discretionary purchases. Do you woo them with bigger portions, lower prices, both, or do nothing at all? If you do nothing for the next quarter, I would expect your cost of sales and other direct operating expenses to drop (as a percent of volume).

Many of you will get a true read out on the economic future as the holiday season ends. Expect oil prices to find an equilibrium price higher than current levels. Grain prices will continue to track oil since most gasoline now has a 10% ethanol blend. Interest rates are very low allowing many businesses and consumers a chance to refinance. Credit remains very tight. Bottled water sales are in decline and tap water is becoming a popular restaurant beverage choice.

Rather than using 2007 or 2008 as your compass, try to put together a logical forecast for your region. If you operate near a major banking center, the layoffs could completely change your business model. Anyone in the Mid-West may see an increase in economic activity as stimulus dollars reach the automobile manufacturing companies. State and local governments have less revenue. If you are located in a capitol metro area, you can expect less traffic.

Americans are consuming more beer. You may want to slow down your wine list expansion. Turn a portion of your wine inventory into cash by selling slow movers by the glass. Don't be afraid to accept a higher cost of sales on these bottles. Your shelves are filled with frozen cash.

Senin, 11 Agustus 2008

Food Cost and Break Even Point

In speaking with many local operators (completely unscientific sample), the consensus estimate is a 12% drop in revenue (year over year). This is tough to swallow with the current trends in food cost percentages. Since the cost of many commodities have risen, the impact of the revenue decline has hurt more than usual. We haven't seen the typical drop in ingredient costs which occur in many recessions.

These higher food costs have caused the break even point to grow rapidly. Many operators have seen a shift from 5 to 10% profit to a loss. What can restaurant managers do to lower their break even point in this challenging environment?

This is a time to promote people with line authority and shed corporate staff. A lower fixed overhead expense is the fastest way to lower the break even point. If you currently work in a corporate staff position, try to get closer to the customer. Abandon your desk post and go into the field. Find ways to improve the efficiency at your locations.

I worked for 3 corporations on either the internal audit staff or as the operations auditor. My travel time averaged over 70% for a 10 year period. In each office, there was a staff room and you were considered under-utilized if the Vice President saw you in the room for over 1 week. My final travel intensive job required close to 90% out-of-town work. When it was time to come in from the field, my boss handed me my paychecks and gave me the week off.

The return for my on site work was enormous. I knew the key operations staff and many of the department heads on all of our key projects. We worked together to solve many issues which simply can't be handled by clever report analysis and endless meetings. You'll find messy walkins, open back doors near closing, unopened boxes of seafood and meat in the garbage, employees with substance problems, invisible over-achievers, well-disguised under-achievers and you'll see many other critical issues first hand.

The break even point will go down as you become a variable cost instead of a fixed expense. You'll be part of the gross margin improvement. Lets say your salary is $1,500 per week and you can visit 2 locations per week. If the sales at each location is $50,000, the combined sales figure is $100,000. If you can make a 1.5% impact, you have covered your expenses at the operation level and completely eliminated your cost at the office.

Perhaps you can have a 3% impact. You will probably be promoted back to the headquarters to make sure the people are not in the staff room for more than one week.

Sabtu, 21 Juni 2008

Keep It Simple Regression

Simple linear regression is an excellent analysis tool for sales forecasting, budgeting and cost efficiency studies. Although the name sounds inviting to many, the number of restaurant operators taking advantage of the power of regression is too small. Today, spreadsheet software performs all the complex calculations required to determine the least square coefficients.

In layman's terms, regression analysis is the process of finding the best straight line through a scatter of data points. Once you take the time to graph your data points, a person with a sharp eye can closely approximate the best fit. The data points in simple regression are plotted on an X-Y graph. The Y axis is the dependent variable and represents the information you are forecasting or analyzing in your model. On the other hand, the X axis contains independent variables.

You may want to plot labor cost as a function of sales. In this example, labor cost depends on sales and is our dependent variable. We would use the Y axis for the labor cost values. Sales would be plotted using the X axis. Most labor cost curves would slope upwards to the right. As our sales increase on the X axis, the labor cost climbs higher. Why would anyone take the time to plot their labor cost as a function of sales? Isn't simple percentage analysis easier and better suited to management meeting discussions?

I believe understanding your fixed labor component is a critical piece of information for any operator. Regression allows you to see both the managerial effectiveness (fixed labor cost) and the staff productivity (slope of the line).

The common formula for the line: Y = a + bX where Y would be our labor cost estimate, a would be our fixed labor expense and b would be the % of sales represented by our variable labor cost. This is a fairly powerful tool and the model requires very little work. A simple list of data points is all you need to feed Excel (Week, Sales, Labor Cost). The formula for calculating the least-square coefficients looks complex and contains Greek alphabet symbols. In reality, its all a matter of finding the best line which a person with a sharp eye can approximate.

Rather than worrying about the mechanics of the formula, trust your eye to show you if the spreadsheet formula worked correctly. Excel has several built-in functions to handle linear regression estimates. The descriptions below are taken directly from Excel's help utility:

INTERCEPT function
Calculates the point at which a line will intersect the y-axis by using existing x-values and y-values. The intercept point is based on a best-fit regression line plotted through the known x-values and known y-values. Use the INTERCEPT function when you want to determine the value of the dependent variable when the independent variable is 0 (zero).

SLOPE function
Returns the slope of the linear regression line through data points in known_y's and known_x's. The slope is the vertical distance divided by the horizontal distance between any two points on the line, which is the rate of change along the regression line.

The INTERCEPT function will answer our fixed labor cost question and the SLOPE function will answer the % of sales spent on variable labor.

Senin, 14 April 2008

Changing Your Break Even Point

After receiving an above average response to my "Do You Know Your Break Even Point?" post, I'd like to answer those who seek ways to lower their number. Since the formula relies on sales and costs, the quickest way to lower your break even point figure is to lower fixed costs.

Governor Jimmy Carter balanced the Georgia budget using zero-based budget techniques. He made department heads justify every cent in their budgets. This is a huge departure from the typical budget process which simply takes the previous year's actual costs and adjusts for inflation and projected revenue increases. Many operators won't see last year's sales volume.

Pressure on sales may require increases in advertising and promotion expenses. If your food and beverage percentage is heading up, now may be a great time to trim your overhead. Motivate top executives with a smaller base pay and a larger bonus potential. Let your key people work hard to find a way to greater profitability and reward them for their effort.

With restaurant operators opening fewer new units across the country, you may find 2008 a great year to renegotiate your lease agreements. Take a look at both real estate leases and business property leases. The Federal Reserve is stimulating the economy with lower rates which may help you when you're talking to leasing firms.

Close all losing units which are nowhere near break even point sales volume. Leaving a money drain open hurts the other viable units.

Once you're through slashing waste and unproductive assets, you can look at increasing sales. Rather than throwing a price increase at customers awash in meal coupons, you could book more banquets. Use banquet sales to cover overhead expenses.

Finally, you may want to schedule major repairs and maintenance activities this year. If you are projecting poor sales during a normally slow month or off season, give your employees an extended vacation and get the repairs done.

Rabu, 12 Maret 2008

Slow Day vs. Busy Day

In my early days with Sodexo, I spent days in frigid Northern Alberta analyzing costs at our largest North American project - Syncrude. If you have a bundle of determination, a study of your slowest day vs. your busiest day is a phenomenal exercise. Since I was specifically paid to improve profits at our Syncrude project, this is where I began.

Slow Day/Busy Day requires taking four inventories in one week for every cost center. The time clock hours need to be available for each of the two days as well. You need to know every employee's job title and department.

Calculate the total sales, labor cost, food cost, beverage cost, linen, paper, chemicals and other supplies. You won't be able to analyze electric power, water, telephone, sewage, garbage pickup, etc. Assume these costs are either fixed or 100% variable. I prefer to let these costs vary with sales.



Start a spreadsheet with all of these sales and expense categories as the left column. Feel free to split labor into Management, Kitchen, Service and Office. Include an estimate for burden (employer's FICA, FUTA, SUTA, Health Care, 401K match, etc.) in your labor expenses. We always had our burden cost available for each project. Make a column called BUSY and another column called SLOW. Enter in all the data from your analysis.

The next two columns are DIFF and VARIABLE. The values in the DIFF column are the difference between BUSY and SLOW. In the VARIABLE column express each value in the DIFF column as a percentage of the sales total in the DIFF column. The VARIABLE percentages are your variable costs as a percentage of sales.

The final column is FIXED. The calculation is a bit trickier but still straight forward. Multiply the sales in BUSY by the percentage in VARIABLE and subtract the result from the BUSY value for the component. For example, if your busy day sales were $10,000 and the variable labor cost is 21%, the variable labor expense is $2,100 for the busy day. If the total labor cost for the busy day is $2,800, the FIXED value is $700.

Go to the bottom of the table and sum the expenses in every column.

A fantastic estimate of your break even point is now possible. Subtract the VARIABLE total from 1 and divide the total FIXED by the result. For example, if your VARIABLE total is 72% and the FIXED total is $1,400, your break even sales is $5,000 or about $1.8 million annual.

The cost of performing this exercise is typically recovered promptly. Everyone in the operation will know you are serious about cost control. Remember, this requires four inventories of all consumables in one single week. Don't waste the effort with bad counts. I used to wake at dawn and return at close after midnight on the slow and busy days.

Minggu, 09 Maret 2008

Do You Know Your Break Even Point?

In my MBA program at Rutgers University, they made sure every graduate could calculate break even points. We were given a myriad of scenarios with a variety of variables. Our tests included irrelevant information to make sure we could focus on the essential formula. Break even point analysis was taught in microeconomics, cost accounting, advanced cost accounting, finance and analytical techniques courses.

The basic formula for determining your break even point follows:
BE=FC/(1-VC%)
BE Break Even Point
FC Fixed Costs
VC Variable Costs

If your business had fixed costs of $500,000 and a 75% variable cost rate, your break even point is $2,000,000. If your fixed costs are $800,000 and your variable costs are only 60%, you'd have the same $2,000,000 break even point.



Which operation would you prefer to own in a growth market? How about a recession?

When a business experiences solid growth, it's possible to increase fixed costs and prosper. The operation with the low variable cost % would be the growth choice. However, you'd want the low fixed cost scenario during recessions.

Think of higher fixed costs as unit expansion. You invest in new FF&E, leasehold improvements, etc. and you expect a big increase in sales and profits. Restaurant expansion may slow this year. We may see units closing and corporate management positions decline in number. Companies are working hard to lower their fixed costs.

When you read about comparable unit sales in the financial press, get your calculators out. If our unit with the $500,000 fixed costs above experienced a 10% drop in sales, fixed costs would need to drop $50,000 to maintain the same break even point. With higher commodity costs, food manufacturers and suppliers are raising prices. Market prices have shot up in major grains and dairy markets. Delivery costs are up due to higher energy prices.

The government may eliminate food and energy from the core inflation rate but we can't ignore these increases. If your sales are in decline and your variable costs are increasing, it's probable last year's profit may not be possible. If you use the previous year's results in your budget calculations, management meetings will be more contentious this year.

The smart operators will look for unique menu solutions which reflect value to customers and help lower variable costs. Buying new equipment is a risky gamble in this climate. It's best to constrain your menu team with the existing equipment. Look carefully and evaluate the work needed to prepare and finish any new menu items. Labor cost is a key component of variable costs.

What items can you add to a dinner menu? A popular pasta dish is a good choice for these profitable meals. The sauce may be reused for several days without additional labor. The pasta is cooked to order and is shelf stable. You can offer profitable add on items like shrimp and chicken. Try to buy the same shrimp and chicken specifications already used in your base menu. We want to limit the number of protein items required overall.

[Please follow this link for more break even point information.]

Jumat, 09 November 2007

Slow Periods

I received above average email volume regarding the October Newsletter. Many of the emails were from software solutions providers. Buried in the pile was this excellent contribution by Marcel Escoffier (FIU):

What you say about slow periods is true, but incomplete. One missed opportunity chains experience is the opportunity to "retire" menu items or. actually, put them on "vacation". Menu bloat is a constant problem and can be reduced using this technique. During forecasted seasonal slow times, the operator should put menu items "on vacation". If in a seaside resort, the operator may reduce the menu for the off-season and concentrate on food items appropriate for that off season's climate / clientele. Less expensive comfort food and special occasion foods might remain on the menu while "touristy" foods might go into a brief retirement. Items with high food costs and relatively low popularity would be the first to go off the menu. Some stars (popular and profitable) might be retired for a period, keeping ones associated with low profit high popularity items (i.e., keep the stuff that makes the "value meal" profitable.) Off season is not the appropriate time to experiment except if experimentation involves new, more efficient preparation methods.

Just some added thoughts. - Marcel Escoffier


Selasa, 30 Oktober 2007

Seasonal Forecasts

When food service operators experience wide percentage swings between in season months and off season months, I recommend a simple analytic tool. The key to using the tool is a list of managers and staff working year round. Once you have this list, it is possible to calculate the monthly labor cost and the estimate of food consumed by these people. In theory, the costs associated with paying and feeding the core team should be the same each month. Sales may fluctuate widely.

As an example, let's use three managers with a monthly salary and benefits expense of $16,000 and food consumption of $540. We'll use six staff employees with a monthly expense of $12,000 and food consumption of $720. Combining the 9 core people, we would pay $28,000 monthly and they would consume $1,260 in food. The table below shows the impact on percentage results as volume changes. While labor cost % spikes during downturns, the employee food consumption should not produce a huge swing. Using dramatic changes from $2,500,000 in sales to $250,000 would only account for a 0.45% change in food cost percentage.



So why do food cost percentages go sky high in off season periods? I believe chronic waste and theft are exposed. However, we can imagine a 100% theft free kitchen and focus on waste. Waste will increase as volume drops if the menu choices do not change in the off season. Producing food for a varied menu with lots of choices in each meal period and menu category puts huge pressure on the forecast team. They need to accurately predict the covers and the expected menu profile. If they miss on the busy weekend, the garbage cans will be loaded with dollars of food cost.

In summary, it's difficult to explain away huge upticks in your food cost percentage with employee meal expenses. Try to decrease the number of menu offerings when you are slow. Watch for repetitive waste issues (e.g. an entire prime rib is cooked and only two portions sold - the rest is used in sandwiches and soup). Slow periods do help daily theft issues to surface.

Selasa, 09 Oktober 2007

Volume Hides Mistakes?

There is an adage in the restaurant industry which states: Volume hides mistakes. I prefer to take the statement and twist it a little. What are these hidden costs? Why does volume hide them so well? Is there a benefit to eliminating these profit killers?

Hidden costs often involve food consumption unexplained by menu analysis. Finding the food consumed without regard for the number of covers or the menu choices made each day is our goal. When do these costs become visible?

Hidden costs stick out on low volume weeks. When there is no volume to hide them you can identify and eliminate these problems. Embrace your slow weeks and use them to improve the operation.

The core staff will often be on duty during your slower business periods. These workers will most likely consume food while on the job and they may also consume food off the premises. It's a mistake to credit your food cost for employee meals. Rather than issuing a credit, I'd recommend including the employee meals in your food cost percentage. If you credit these meals, you will miss a control opportunity.

Some operators see huge swings when their volume drops. The biggest moves I've seen are from the high 20s to low 40s. If your food cost percentage is 28% at peak volume and 42% at your low point, you use 50% more food per portion served to a customer. Careful analysis of employee food consumption can help identify major problems.

Imagine someone is robbing a case of shrimp each week. The impact of this activity would clearly be greater when volume drops. Your big volume weeks will offer cover for these thieves. Try not to offer additional cover by creating overly generous employee meal credits in your calculations.

Selasa, 09 Januari 2007

Slow Cooked BBQ Requires Careful Planning

BBQ is becoming very popular in a lot of new places. My clients with BBQ oriented menus include a professionally managed public golf club and an authentic BBQ in midtown Manhattan (both use a Southern Pride Smoker . While BBQ chicken and ribs are found just about anywhere, pulled pork, tritips and Texas-style brisket are relatively new to many regions of the country.

Proper BBQ takes time. The meat needs to marinate for hours and the smoky flavor is provided by hours of slow cooking in a warm pit or smoker. If you expect a crowd on the weekend, the meat order needs to be complete on Wednesday (at the latest). After an early delivery Thursday morning, preparation begins with trimming excess fat, cartilage and deckle. The meat may be cooked on the bone or boneless.

After the trimming process, the marinating begins with a dry and/or wet mop. The marinated meat will need to rest for a day or more in many operations. With the slow cooking process in the near future, veteran BBQ artisans are already watching both the calendar and the clock.

Since purchasing needs to take place days ahead of service, proper forecasting is at the heart of BBQ operations. When buying the meat, it’s necessary to be completely fluent with trim factors and yields. Let’s look at three popular BBQ items and discuss the yields one may expect:

Brisket:
A big Beef Brisket 118 will weigh about 20 pounds. Some brisket buyers choose the boneless version – Beef Brisket 120 – weighing in at about 12 pounds. Some favor smoking the brisket with bones. Others like the less fatty, fully trimmed version.

The bone in version will yield about half when fully cooked and the boneless will yield about 2/3. Our 20# purchase will yield 20 generous 8 ounce servings for platters or 40 sandwiches. If you allow your customers to specify lean only, the yield falls substantially.

Pulled Pork:
If you like to use Fresh Ham, Boneless 402B, you’ll be purchasing large pieces weighing between 20 and 30 pounds. A Boston Butt, Boneless 406A will weigh about 8 pounds and is really shoulder meat.

Both cuts will yield over 2/3 fully cooked but will plummet to half if the customer specifies lean only.

Ribs:
Most BBQ operations carefully choose the rib specifications. A rack of Back Ribs can average anywhere from 1.25 pounds to over 2.25 pounds. A rack of St. Louis Spareribs can weigh between 1.5 and 3 pounds. Some operators prefer the heavy, untrimmed racks which can be over 5 pounds. The skeletons are identical but age and feed vary. Customers usually order ribs by the rack, half rack or by the number of bones (not by weight).

My clients study their sales data carefully using the prior week, previous year and weather forecasts before placing their pre-weekend orders. They forecast the servings and use models to calculate the optimal order. Since ribs are often sold frozen, many well managed BBQ operations use long term predictions to go long when prices are favorable. All this math is rewarded with great profits since the best tasting BBQ is served straight from the smoker.


Click Here For More Information

Senin, 06 November 2006

Cost Benefit Analysis

Every business decision has a cost associated with the execution. If the strategy was sound, the benefit derived from the action will exceed the cost incurred executing the tasks. Cost benefit analysis involves the study of results in relationship to the cost of the activity.

The absolute rule (applicable in all cases) is the cost of information may not exceed the expected gain. Any decision which will produce a benefit less than the cost to make the decision, execute the strategy and monitor results is a waste of time. Most decision makers try to filter out the minutiae in order to focus their attention on high impact activities.

As you start any campaign to improve profits through improved food cost control, it is imperative to discover areas which will have the greatest impact for the time and resources required. Try to locate activities which are performed over and over again. Isolate activities which are not consistently performed and activities which have a major impact on the client experience.

A second rule is to avoid destructive cost cutting activities. For example, you may discover the most popular menu item has been chronically over-portioned by the production staff. It would be quite dangerous to dramatically cut the portion size back to the standard in this case. Customers have come to expect the bigger portion and will immediately notice severe reductions. It is wiser to acknowledge the true portion size and develop a less obvious strategy to deal with the issue.

Opportunity cost looks at both missed opportunities and the risks avoided. You have some extra capital to put in play. Do you use it as a down payment on a new location? Would a new advance in POS technology offer a big opportunity? Would an advertising campaign bring more covers to existing locations? These decisions all involve risks and they also involve opportunity costs.

If you do nothing, the money goes into a bank account and earns 2 to 5% interest. This simple activity produces a key decision variable - the risk free value of money. All decisions should be weighed against this risk free return.

Every decision you make needs to be one you are authorized to complete. The organization does not need the wait staff fretting over the selection of a vendor for a new phone system. If you stick to your area of control, you'll have a better chance to make great decisions. If you begin to look at your operation through the CBA lens, you will begin to overlook insignificant issues and focus on real problems and opportunities.


Click Here For More Information
Related Posts Plugin for WordPress, Blogger...